Small batch cheesecake.
Baked weekly in Newark, DE.
Limited drops — order ahead.
Orders close every Tuesday at 12 PM.
Home-based · Pickup only · Newark, DE
Next pickup
Wed · 6–8 PM
This Week's Batch
One flavor. One drop.
Drop 029
Late Night Lemmy
Smooth lemon cheesecake with fresh-squeezed lemon juice and hand-zested citrus, layered over a buttery cracker crust and finished with a light crumb and lemon zest garnish. Baked fresh in Newark, Delaware for local pickup.
- Pickup dayWed · 6–8 PM
- Backup pickupThu · 12–4 PM
- Available20 of 20 left
- Price$10
Sold out
Last 4 batches in a row
10+
Repeat customers weekly
4.9★
Average pickup review
How it works
Three simple steps.
01
Order
Pick your flavor and pickup day.
02
Pay
Card, Apple Pay, or Google Pay.
03
Pick up
Fresh, boxed, and ready for you.
Feedback Rewards
Share your bite.
Tell us what you loved or share a photo for a chance to receive a discount or early access to the next batch.
Leave feedback
Our story
Built around flavor, quality, and consistency.
Mama's Cheesecake started in a home kitchen with one rule: if it isn't the best cheesecake we've ever made, it doesn't leave the door.
Read the storyFrequently asked
Local pickup, answered.
- Where is pickup in Newark, DE?
- Pickup is in Newark, Delaware. The exact pickup address is sent by text the morning of your pickup day after your order is confirmed.
- Can I walk in or get delivery?
- Mama's Cheesecake is a home-based small business. There are no walk-ins, orders are pickup only, and delivery isn't available yet. Orders are placed on the website only.
- Do you serve Wilmington and New Castle County?
- Yes — customers drive in from Wilmington, Bear, Middletown and across New Castle County every week. Local pickup only; no delivery at this time.
- How often do you bake?
- One premium small batch of 20 cheesecakes is baked fresh each week. When the batch sells out, it's gone until the next drop.
- How far in advance should I order?
- Weekly drops typically sell out within a few days. Order earlier in the week to guarantee a cheesecake from the current Newark batch.
- What makes it a premium cheesecake?
- Real cream cheese, fresh dairy, hand-zested citrus and a buttery cracker crust pressed by hand. Every cheesecake is baked low-and-slow, chilled overnight, and boxed the day of pickup.